How do I vet AI tools before using them at work?

Question

Description:

I need a practical checklist to judge AI vendors’ claims about accuracy, privacy, bias, and integration costs before procurement. What tests, metrics, and pilot designs can I use to validate performance on our data, and what contract terms or questions protect against data misuse and vendor lock-in? Also, what red flags should prompt us to walk away?

3 Answers

Sort by:

Want to answer?

Join the conversation and help others by sharing your insights.

Log in to your account or create a new one — it only takes a minute and gives you the ability to post answers, vote, and build your expert profile.

Log in or Register ›

Answer 1 · 2025-08-09T02:48:19+00:00

Once I bought a subscription to a shiny AI scheduler because it promised to "never double book" and then it sent my partner three invites for the same dinner while also CCing my boss on a personal note, which led to a week of awkward explanations and me hiding receipts in weird places. I mention that because vetting AI is part tech and part gut feeling, and you will want to catch both the math mistakes and the weird social ones.

For practical checks run a shadow test on your live traffic plus a held out dataset that mirrors edge cases, measure precision recall and calibration across subgroups, track drift and latency, and run adversarial or injection tests. Validate privacy with synthetic input attacks, check differential privacy parameters or encryption in transit and at rest, and demand provenance of training data. Pilot in "read only" mode then a phased canary with KPIs and rollback gates. Contractually require data ownership, deletion proofs, audit rights, portability of models and weights, SLA uptime and error budgets, indemnity for data breaches, and exit assistance. Ask for SOC2 reports, third party audits, model cards, and patch cadence. Walk away if they promise perfect accuracy, refuse audits, block exports, or have opaque training data or subcontractor chains.

Answer 2 · 2025-08-10T12:36:43+00:00

Demand adversarial, calibration and drift tests in a timeboxed pilot plus independent audits, exportable checkpoints, right to audit and guaranteed data deletion or walk away

Answer 3 · 2025-09-25T19:25:57+00:00

When vetting AI tools, prioritize the principle of least privilege—ensure the tool only accesses data necessary for its function to minimize exposure. Test how it handles sensitive information by running controlled scenarios with anonymized or synthetic data that mimics your real environment. For performance validation, focus on precision and recall metrics relevant to your use case rather than generic accuracy claims. Contractually, insist on clear clauses about data ownership and a strict timeline for secure deletion after termination. A major red flag is vendors unwilling to provide transparency into their model's decision processes or refusing independent security assessments—these could hide serious risks you won't detect until it's too late.