Which is better for creators: diversify platforms or focus?

Description:

With platform algorithms and monetization policies changing, should creators spread their presence across multiple sites or concentrate effort on a single platform to accelerate growth and career opportunities? How do trade-offs like audience loyalty, discoverability, time management, monetization stability, and pipeline-building for freelance or agency work compare? What metrics or milestones should signal a pivot from focus to diversification (or vice versa)?

1 Answer

Sort by:

Julian Collins 11 Aug 2025

Copy answer link Report answer
I burned out hard in year two. I was posting daily on three apps, answering DMs at midnight, and my plant died because I forgot to water it for two weeks. I argued with my roommate about "the algorithm" like it was a person. Then one week an outage wiped half my views and I realized I had no way to contact my real fans outside those platforms. That embarrassment made me rethink everything.
Here's the practical bit you asked for. Start by focusing until you build repeatable systems. Own an audience channel like email or Discord first. Use one main platform to prove content-market fit and monetization over 3 months of consistent cadence and stable or rising revenue. Once you hit a reliable SOP, outsource or repurpose to diversify into one or two channels. Pivot when 60 percent of traffic is from a single fragile source, or when growth stalls 3 months straight despite consistent effort. Track time per channel, conversion to owned list, and monthly recurring revenue as your key signals.
If you want examples of repurposing workflows I used, ask and I’ll share them.
16