The pros and cons of accepting equity as part of your salary?

Question

Description:

My offer replaces part of the cash salary with equity. What are the real-world pros and cons I should weigh before accepting equity-based pay, and how does it affect my career choices and personal finances? Please cover: the differences between RSUs, NSOs/ISOs and restricted stock; typical vesting schedules, cliffs and acceleration clauses; tax consequences (including 83(b) and AMT where relevant); liquidity and secondary-market options; dilution and future financing risk; how to value the grant versus cash (modeling upside scenarios); effects on borrowing, emergency savings and diversification; negotiation levers (more salary vs more equity, strike price adjustments, accelerated vesting on exit); and warning signs or red flags that make equity a poor substitute for cash. Practical examples or simple calculations to compare offers would be helpful.

5 Answers

Sort by:

Aiden Lewis 9 Aug 2025

Copy answer link Report answer
Have you thought about how equity actually changes who controls your timing and choices in life? Why does illiquidity and contract fine print matter more than headline grant size when you want to buy a house or quit? Look beyond upside and ask about liquidation preferences that can leave common stock worthless even at a "successful" exit, post‑termination exercise windows that force decisions under stress, forced sell-to-cover tax withholdings, and whether lenders will treat your grant as income.
Convert offers by using a simple cash‑equivalent:
cash = shares*(expected exit price − strike)*P(exit)*(1−tax)*liquidity haircut.
Try different Ps and haircuts to see when equity beats salary. What risk will you accept when life demands cash pronto?
20
Anonymous 10 Aug 2025

Copy answer link Report answer
Black‑Scholes assumes public liquidity and so can overvalue private options. Treat grants by probability‑weighting future payoff, then discount for time and illiquidity.
Example: 5,000 options, strike $2, expected exit $20 in 5 years, 30% chance → gross = (20−2)*5,000*0.3 = $27,000. Discount 20%/yr ≈ $10,800, minus taxes and 30% liquidity haircut ≈ $7,600 cash‑equivalent.
Use that when trading salary for equity and push for cashless exercise or shorter post‑termination exercise windows.
19
Jayden Baker 17 Aug 2025

Copy answer link Report answer
This topic always takes me back to when I was fresh outta college, weighing an offer with a chunk of equity instead of cold hard cash. My Aunt Mae, who somehow became my financial guru, told me to think of equity like a garden—you gotta tend it and wait, but the payoff could be juicy. I took her words seriously but had no clue then about all those tax codes and vesting schedules until the first tax form showed up looking like a foreign language book.
Now digging into your question — picking equity over salary means you’re placing a bet on the company’s future growth, but it's important to realize that RSUs are usually simpler since you own the shares after vesting. NSOs and ISOs are trickier ‘cause they hinge on exercising options, and ISOs can goose your AMT liability—which sucker-punched my buddy last year after that startup exit. Unlike RSUs which hit you with tax when vested, options often hit you twice: on exercise and then sale.
Vesting schedules with cliffs mean you’re probably locked in for at least a year before seeing anything tangible — if you jump ship too soon, you might get zilch. Also watch out for acceleration clauses because they can be sweet in an acquisition but sometimes only kick in under specific scenarios. When it comes to valuing these grants versus cash, think about not just the strike price or grant date value but also how illiquid your shares are—no sense having stock that’s just collecting dust if it slows buying a house or emergency cash needs.
A quick practical angle: say you get 10k options at $5 strike price hoping for that $20 exit. Set your personal “success” bar based on risk tolerance—not everyone’s gonna hit big exits; and don’t underestimate dilution if there’s more fundraising ahead—the pie might get sliced thinner.
One thing rarely mentioned is how lenders look at this stuff—they often won’t count unvested equity as income so it can put a wrench in mortgage applications or loans, unlike solid salary cash flow. When negotiating, pushing for accelerated vesting upon change-of-control can be huge peace of mind. Red flags? If the company’s got vague financing plans or no clear path to liquidity beyond “hopeful IPO,” that’s a warning sign to keep your bank account robust before betting your future on potentially worthless paper.
Long story short: equity is like planting corn instead of grabbing cornflakes for breakfast—it could feed you big down the line or leave you hungry right now. Balance it carefully with your day-to-day money needs and life plans!
18
Anonymous 12 Aug 2025

Copy answer link Report answer
Minor technical nitpick: an 83b election applies to restricted stock you actually receive at grant, not to RSUs that are only promises until delivery. Equity trades cash for optional upside but raises tax, liquidity and concentration risk. RSUs taxed at vest, NSOs taxed on exercise, ISOs can trigger AMT.Watch cliffs, acceleration, secondaries, dilution and cap table. Example: 10000 options strike $1, exit $3 equals $20000 pre tax.
18

Want to answer?

Join the conversation and help others by sharing your insights.

Log in to your account or create a new one — it only takes a minute and gives you the ability to post answers, vote, and build your expert profile.

Log in or Register ›

Accepted Answer · 2025-08-14T01:23:43+00:00

Think of equity as a bet ticket, not a paycheck. A few lesser-discussed things to watch: Qualified Small Business Stock (QSBS) can wipe out capital gains after five years if the company qualifies. Options valuation deserves a Black-Scholes or simple expected-value model that discounts by probability of exit and liquidity.

Try this quick calc: 5,000 options, strike $2. Scenario A: fail (50%) payoff $0. B: modest exit $10 (40%) payoff (10-2)*5,000=$40k. C: big exit $50 (10%) payoff (50-2)*5,000=$240k. Expected pre-tax value = 0*.5 + 40k*.4 + 240k*.1 = $28k, then subtract taxes and illiquidity.
Negotiate refresh grants, pro rata rights and double-trigger acceleration, or more salary if runway is thin. Keep emergency cash and cap concentration under 10-20%. Get a tax advisor for 83(b)/ISO planning and lender effects.